How to write a great story prompt
Last updated: 2026-11-20
A great story prompt tells the AI who the characters are, where they are, what problem they face, what's at stake, how the story should feel and whose eyes we see it through. You don't need all six every time, but each one you add makes the story more yours. This guide uses Magic Story's generator, but the ideas work for any kind of writing.
What makes a good story prompt?
A good prompt is specific about people and situation and leaves the AI room to write the scene. One or two clear sentences usually beat a long list of demands.
Think of a prompt as a pitch, not a script. Tell the AI what's interesting about this story (the problem, the secret, the risk) and let it handle the sentences.
What are the parts of a prompt?
A strong prompt has six parts: who, where, the problem, the stakes, the feel and the point of view.
- Who: a character with a detail or two that makes them real: a job, a habit, a fear, a way of talking. Names help.
- Where: a specific place and time. "A lighthouse on the last night of summer" does more work than "the seaside".
- The problem: what goes wrong or what someone wants: a lost key, a locked door, a rival, a curse.
- The stakes: what happens if they fail. Small stakes are fine for a bedtime story; big ones suit a thriller.
- The feel: cozy, eerie, funny, epic or bittersweet. On Magic Story this is mostly set with options (see below).
- Point of view: first person ("I"), second person ("you"), third person, or alternating perspectives.
What do before-and-after prompts look like?
The "after" versions below add a place, a problem and stakes to a vague idea. Each is short, but each gives the AI a real story to tell.
- Before: "A dragon story."
After: "A small dragon who can't breathe fire yet is put in charge of lighting the village lanterns on the longest night of the year." - Before: "A romance."
After: "Two rival bakers enter the same village competition. When a storm knocks out the power, they have to share one oven to finish in time." - Before: "A scary story."
After: "A night-shift librarian keeps finding notes in a 200-year-old handwriting tucked into the books she shelves. Tonight, the latest one is addressed to her." - Before: "A mystery."
After: "The prize pumpkin vanishes from the county fair the night before judging, and the only witness is a very sleepy goat." - Before: "Sci-fi."
After: "The ship's AI wakes the youngest crew member early: everyone else is still in cryosleep, and something is knocking on the hull from outside." - Before: "A fantasy story."
After: "A mercenary and the sorceress who hired her must cross a frozen mountain pass. They don't trust each other, and only one of them knows the map is fake."
Notice what the "after" prompts don't do: they don't list every event or script the dialogue. They set up a problem and let the story find its way.
Should I use the options or write it in the prompt?
Use the options for anything the options cover, and keep the prompt for the people and the situation. Options are read reliably and keep your prompt short.
On Magic Story's generator pages you can set:
- Who it's for: Young kids 3 to 6, Kids 7 to 10, Tweens 10 to 13, Teens 13+ or Adults.
- Intensity: Gentle, Exciting or Intense.
- Tone: for example cozy, funny, eerie or epic.
- Point of view: 1st person, 2nd person (you), 3rd person or alternating perspectives.
- Pacing, dialogue and the big moment: how fast it moves, how much people talk, and what the story builds to.
- Length: Normal (~1,000 words), Longer (~2,000, 2 tokens) or Longest (~3,500, 3 tokens).
- Ending: for example happy, twist, cliffhanger or bittersweet.
- Leave out: anything you'd rather not see, such as spiders, storms or sad endings.
- Story elements: each of the 83 story types has its own list, such as the dragon story generator's kinds of dragons.
If the prompt and an option disagree, the result can be muddled. If you pick "Gentle", don't also ask for a terrifying chase.
How do I use saved characters and worlds in a prompt?
Build a character or a world once and reuse it, so you don't have to describe the same people and places in every prompt.
- The Character Creator stores a character's look, personality, voice, backstory, strengths, fears and limits.
- Worlds store a setting: its places, rules, secrets, regulars and story hooks.
With a character and a world in place, your prompt can be one line: "The first night at the lighthouse inn after the storm."
How do I steer the story once it starts?
Steer with the choices after each part instead of rewriting your prompt. Magic Story offers 3 choices for what happens next after each part.
- Pick a choice to follow one of the suggested directions, or write your own.
- Continue to let the story carry on as it is.
- Rewrite if a part didn't land.
- More exciting or Gentler to change the intensity of a part without starting over.
Your first story is free at any length, plus 3 free chapters, rewrites or edits on it. After that, 1 token covers a Normal part plus its next part (see pricing).
What should I avoid in a prompt?
Avoid anything the content policy rules out, because the story will be stopped: nothing sexual or graphic, no real or identifiable people and no copyrighted characters.
- Don't name celebrities, people you know, or characters from films, books or games; invent your own, or retell a public domain fairy tale.
- Don't put your child's full name, school or address in a prompt; a first name or a nickname is plenty.
- Don't stack contradictions ("shy but bold, slow but fast").
If a story you think is fine gets blocked, rephrase it and see the help center. Tokens spent on a blocked story are returned automatically.
Where can I get prompt ideas?
Each generator page offers daily prompt ideas, and signed-in users can re-roll 5 fresh AI ideas for 1 token. You can also browse scenario packs or read the guide to writing a story for craft tips.